Modi’s Shrinking Margin: How Domestic Unrest Raises the Risk of Escalation in South Asia

By: Philip White

Since July,  India has witnessed a wave of protesters challenging Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s economic policies and purported democratic and educational misconduct. The demonstrations pose an internal challenge to Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and an external threat to regional security. Pressure at home could narrow Modi’s options in a crisis with Pakistan and predispose him to escalation rather than restraint. 

In a rivalry between two nuclear-armed powers, the consequences of India’s domestic instability could reach far beyond South Asia.

The demonstrations, organized by the newly established, youth-led Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), began in June 2026 and have since grown into a major uprising, especially in New Delhi. The protests stem from unprecedented allegations of misconduct by the BJP government. These include the disenfranchisement of over 130 million registered voters by the Election Commission of India and the invalidation of the May 2026 national medical-college entrance exam, an extremely consequential juncture in many young Indians’ lives. However, these events were only the precipitants of a much larger Gen Z sentiment of government and economic neglect with reportedly 9.9 percent of Indians aged fifteen to twenty-nine and 20 percent of college graduates aged twenty-five to twenty-nine experiencing unemployment and an even greater share experiencing underemployment. Additionally, Indian households’ one-year inflation expectations hover around 10 percent, well above the current headline inflation rate of 5.54 percent, suggesting that Indian consumers expect prices to rise considerably faster than current inflation figures indicate. 

Institutional failures and  economic difficulties facing young Indians put Modi and the BJP in a precarious political position, especially with upcoming 2027 Bellwether State elections. That pressure carries consequences beyond domestic politics, because, historically, Pakistan policy is where Modi has long turned to project strength.

Since taking office in 2014, Modi has moved India’s Pakistan posture away from the sustained dialogue and economic normalization pursued by his predecessor, Manmohan Singh, toward a more confrontational posture. The 2016 Uri attack prompted cross-border strikes and the 2019 Pulwama bombing brought the Balakot airstrikes, the first Indian air raid on Pakistani territory since 1971. In May 2025, Operation Sindoor answered the Pahalgam attack, in which militants killed twenty-five Hindu tourists and a local shepherd, and went further still, introducing cruise missiles and offensive drones into the protracted conflict. The Modi administration;’s drastic military reprisals are indicative of a leader not averse to the use of hard power to achieve deterrence objectives. 

That posture has also paid political dividends at home, especially among the Hindu nationalist base of the BJP. Additionally, such a posture enjoys broad public support, as 78 percent of the Indian populace hold an unfavorable view of Pakistan. Because his base and the wider public favor confrontation with Pakistan, Modi may seek to leverage that sentiment to consolidate support amid domestic unrest, should the opportunity arise. 

In the past, Modi could accept international pressure to restrain his administration’s reprisals because he could afford to appear slightly weaker on national security. With his standing weakened by recent protests, that calculus has shifted. If Pakistan or its proxies were to carry out another attack on Indian or disputed territory, a forceful response could rally public support behind Modi, and he could be less inclined to heed foreign calls for restraint. The result is an Indian government less receptive to outside pressure and more predisposed to escalatory retaliation, and a more unstable region as a consequence. 

Averting this outcome will require progress on two fronts.

Domestically, the Modi government must address the immediate concerns of the CJP in regard to the educational and electoral misconduct perpetrated over the last six months. While New Delhi has taken some steps to address these concerns, including the removal of both the Deputy Election Commissioner and the Higher Education Secretary, it now faces the difficult, long-term task of restoring confidence in these vital systems. Additionally, Modi must take a more proactive stance on the high unemployment rate of Indian youth and decrease the perception of rampant future inflation among Indian households. If he can address these concerns and bring greater political stability to India, the pressure could ease; however, these domestic challenges are extremely complex to resolve, and as such there must also be a concerted effort by India, Pakistan, and the global community to mitigate the outset of future crises through peacebuilding mechanisms.

Reestablishing robust diplomatic channels between both nations’ leaders and military commands should be the immediate priority, as it gives both governments a means of deescalation before a crisis devolves. Additionally, the renormalization of economic ties, which could begin with the restoration of the Indus Waters Treaty previously placed in abeyance following the Pahalgam attack, is another priority, as are joint efforts to address Pakistan-based militant groups that threaten India, the most likely trigger of the next crisis. 

Previous
Previous

Counting Down to the Wrong War

Next
Next

Japan Has an Organized Crime Problem, and It’s Not the One You’re Thinking Of