By: Eva Caravassilis
Article 7, Section 2(g) of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) defines “Persecution” as “the intentional and severe deprivation of fundamental rights contrary to international law by reason of the identity of the group or collectivity”.Alternatively, Article 7(1)(h) defines the act as “against an identifiable group or collectivity on political, racial, national, ethnic, cultural, religious,...or other grounds that are universally recognized as impermissible under international law.” This article will focus on 3 countries in particular: Libya, Nigeria, and Somalia. The conditions unique to each country I will describe concerning religious violence against Christians and Muslims best fit Article 7(1)(h)’s definition of the criminal act itself.
According to Open Doors, the 2026 World Watch List states that “an estimated 388 million [approximately 1 in 7] Christians face high levels of persecution and discrimination for their faith,” with 6 countries in Africa now registered as having “extreme” persecution levels. Open Door defines Christian persecution as “any hostility experienced as a result of proclaiming the name of Jesus.” A country’s persecution score is on a 100-point scale across 6 categories: private, family, community, national, church life, and violence. The minimum score required to label a country’s level of persecution as “Extreme” is 81/100. During the reporting period from 1 October 2024 to 30 September 2025, 3,490 of 4,849 believers were killed, roughly 72%, for their faith in Nigeria, which ranks number 7, alone by ethnic, government, and militant groups including Boko Haram, the Islamic State West Africa Province (ISWAP), Fulani ethnic militias, and Mahmuda. In Libya which ranks number 9, approximately 36,300 migrant Christian workers, roughly 0.5% of “adherents in country”, face “extreme” levels of persecution. Somalia, whose World Watch List score is 94/100, ranks number 2 overall. Unlike Libya and Nigeria, Somalia’s constitution “requires all laws to comply with the principles of [S]haria”, bans the propagation of other religions and subordinates all laws to Sharia. While Libya’s 2011 Constitution declares “Islam as the state religion and Shari’a as the main source of legislation”, all Libyans are “equal” before the law.
Libya:
Following the overthrow of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011 by Libyan rebel forces backed by NATO airstrikes, Libya’s 2011 transitional Constitutional Declaration and 2017 Draft Constitution declare Islam as Libya’s religion and Sharia law as the main source of legislation. The U.S. State Department’s 2019 report on International Religious Freedom in Libya shows that competing interests between authorities and armed groups, with ethnic and religious minorities being situated outside the Sunni Arab majority, have led to internal divisions. These reports persist in 2026, according to the USCIRF, leaving religious minorities exposed to violence and discrimination with little accountability. Tensions between the Tripoli-based Government of National Unity (GNU) and General Haftar’s Libyan National Army (LNA) have persisted since the LNA attacked the capital in April 2019. However, the conflict has since shifted into a prolonged political stalemate following the 2020 ceasefire. In Tripoli, the Rada Special Deterrence Forces continue to harass Christians. In Benghazi, LNA-aligned Madkhali Salafist groups target Sufi Muslim clerics and followers, while the 2019 report documented the harassment of sub-Saharan Christian refugees.
Along with Christians, ethnic minorities also stood apart from the Sunni majority. Many Amazigh (Berbers) are Ibadi Muslims, and the eastern government issued a 2017 edict accusing the group of “deviance” and of following an “infidel doctrine”. Additionally, after the beheading of 21 Coptic Orthodox Christians in February 2015 and the murder of 30 Ethiopian Christians in April, many Coptic Christians from Egypt ultimately returned to their home countries due to fear of the increasing risk of physical assault, abduction, torture, unlawful killing, sexual assault, and rape. Many of these crimes against innocent civilians are left unreported and ultimately go unrecognized, making it increasingly difficult to prevent these atrocities from proliferating any further.
Nigeria:
According to BTI’s 2026 Nigeria Country Report, ethnicity and religion remain influential in Nigerian politics under President Tinubu, while corruption continues to affect public institutions at both federal and state levels. Founded in 1978, the Izala Movement began as “a reformist group aiming to…promote the Sunnah” and sought to “spread anti-Sufism throughout Northern Nigeria, including to Maiduguri," Boko Haram’s origins. Interestingly enough, Boko Haram’s founder, Mohammed Yusuf, was mentored by prominent Izala preacher Ja’far Mahmud Adam but later broke ties over ideological differences concerning education, government, and armed jihad. Many scholars treat Izala as separate from Boko Haram, and more so as “a result of fierce intra-Salafi competition for audiences.” However, this provided the ideological inspiration for a “culture of violence” through the purist agendas of various Islamist terror groups like Boko Haram, ISWAP, Ansaru, and more recently, Lakurawa and Mahmuda. This added an ethno-religious dimension to the violence led by the Fulani Ethnic Militia (FEM) against Christians and Hausa Muslims. Militants attacked Christian villages in the Middle Belt as well as in the south, “burning homes and churches, kidnapping, raping, and murdering”, as a result of the farmer-herder conflict. The conflict has intensified violence through disputes over land, water, and grazing access, while ethnic and religious divisions have deepened communal mistrust and shaped how attacks are understood. In recent years, the gradual influx of Fulani militants from surrounding countries has increased the threat of violence in those regions.
Somalia:
Unlike Libya and Nigeria, Somalia’s provisional federal constitution makes Islam the state religion, stipulates that all laws must comply with the general principles of Sharia, and requires the President to be Muslim. The judiciary relies on xeer (traditional and customary law), Sharia, and the penal code. Each area regulates and enforces religious expression individually and inconsistently. By the mid-2000s, al-Shabaab had emerged as the radical military wing of the Islamic Courts Union (ICU), controlling large portions of central and southern Somalia by the late-2000s, drawing support from criminal economies, and exploiting federal fragmentation and regional disputes. It formally affiliated with al-Qaeda in 2012. Christianity is effectively criminalized, and Muslim-background believers also face execution by al-Shabaab, honor killings by their clans, and total social exclusion. For example, in April 2015, at Garissa University in Kenya, militants killed 148 people after separating Christians from Muslims and singling out Christians for execution. And “on or around February 10” 2017, suspected al-Shabaab militants killed Somali Christian convert Faduma Osman and her 11-year-old son and seriously wounded her husband during an attack on their home near Mogadishu, Somalia. The insurgent group continues to sustain itself through traditional organized crime, like smuggling and extortion, making it resilient and difficult to dislodge.
Because the ICC has no police force and solely depends on the compliance of State Parties, or sovereign countries that have formally ratified the treaty, to make arrests, prosecuting the leaders and individuals responsible for proliferating religious violence against Christians and Muslims alike is an unreliable process at the international level. Since Libya and Somalia have not ratified the Statute, the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) must refer a situation to the ICC to grant the Court jurisdiction in investigating matters that occurred within their territories. In 2011, the UNSC referred Libya’s case to the ICC, but after Muammar Gaddafi was captured and killed in October 2011, the Court formally terminated proceedings against him. On December 11, 2020, the ICC concluded its preliminary investigation on Nigeria, finding that Boko Haram and the Nigerian military have committed war crimes and crimes against humanity. They also concluded that “Nigerian authorities failed to…investigate and prosecute these crimes”; however, the Office of the Prosecutor has yet to request a formal investigation by the Pre-Trial Chamber in Nigeria for such a grave issue. The UNSC has not referred a case against Somalia, despite its high ranking on Open Door’s Watchlist. An ICC investigation in Somalia and Nigeria is both necessary and crucial to foster accountability and ensure the safety and security of all victims involved.